News: These Pictures Show How the Note7's Death Could Have Been Avoided

These Pictures Show How the Note7's Death Could Have Been Avoided

These Pictures Show How the Note7's Death Could Have Been Avoided

The Note7 fireworks bonanza was unprecedented in scope. A recent report suggests that Samsung could lose upwards of $20 billion in lost profit due to this fiasco.

Update: See the end of this article for Samsung's findings on what happened.

Speculation abounds as we wait for Samsung's official report to come out regarding the cause of the Note7's untimely demise, but a recent teardown from Instrumental (done with fire extinguisher in hand) shows a critical design flaw that could be the cause the rash of explosions and fires associated with the phone.

Instrumental, a company that specializes in assisting companies with detecting and fixing issues with their products, found that Samsung had violated a key engineering principle in designing a handset: Not accounting for battery bloat.

Image via Instrumental

Lithium polymer batteries naturally expand as they cycle through charges and depletion. Engineers have to account for this and leave ample room within the battery compartment (usually about 10% of the battery's total size for ceiling clearance) for the battery to safely swell into.

The Note7's 3,500 mAh battery was literally crammed into the phone with incredibly little room for the battery to breathe. In fact, the researchers theorized that their test unit was itself under pressure, as it had no ceiling clearance against its rear housing.

A great example of ceiling clearance. Note the gap between the battery and wireless charging contact on this Galaxy S6. Image by Amboy Manalo/Gadget Hacks

Having the battery entombed in a rigid pocket of CNC-machined aluminum and glass proved to be a recipe for disaster. The Note7's battery would sometimes squeeze into itself as it had nowhere to go, and apply undue pressure to its already thin cell walls that separate negative and positive layers. Excess heat is created when the layers rub against each other and, in some cases, it can get hot enough to set the phone ablaze.

An example of battery bloat. The battery is normally flat, note the swollen appearance. Image by SisterWife18/Pixabay

The report goes on to make a damning assertion:

...Samsung took a deliberate step towards danger, and their existing test infrastructure and design validation process failed them. They shipped a dangerous product. That this is possible at one of the top consumer electronic companies in the world is humbling

This certainly won't be the last time we here of this issue. Samsung has yet to publish an official report regarding the Note7's untimely demise, and we should hold off on drawing any final conclusions. We will keep you updated with any future news, especially when Samsung releases official results of its investigation into the matter.

Update: January 23, 2017

Samsung has revealed the findings of their investigation and have concluded that batteries from both themselves and a third-party were the cause of the fires—not because of limited space in the phones to accommodate "bloat" from the batteries. You can see their results in the infographic below.

Image via Samsung
Cover image by Instrumental

3 Comments

Non-removable battery which Samsung stole idea from Apple.
So, it got punished

Non-removable batteries have become the norm for better or worse. It's just sad that such a major company felt so compelled to rush the Note 7 that it compromised safety. Let's hope they've learned their lesson and take their time with s8...

Lithium polymer batteries naturally expand as they cycle through charges and depletion.

The picture shows a lithium ION battery... Not a LiPo....

Share Your Thoughts

  • Hot
  • Latest